Print Reading Mode Back to Calendar Return
  Regular-Community Services   # 27.       
Board of Supervisors Sustainability  
Meeting Date: 04/09/2024  
Brief Title:    Update on Climate Action and Adaptation Plan Strategy Framework
From: Leslie Lindbo, Director, Department of Community Services
Staff Contact: Kristen Wraithwall, Sustainability Manager, Department of Community Services, x8047
Supervisorial District Impact: Countywide

Subject
Receive update on Climate Action and Adaptation Plan (CAAP) Strategy, Measure, Action Framework and Adoption Timeline. (No general fund impact) (Lindbo/Wraithwall) (Est. Time: 10 min)
Recommended Action
Receive update on Climate Action and Adaptation Plan (CAAP) Strategy, Measure, Action Framework and Adoption Timeline. 
Strategic Plan Goal(s)
Sustainable Environment
Reason for Recommended Action/Background
History
On September 29, 2020, the Yolo County Board of Supervisors passed Resolution No. 20-114, titled "A Resolution Declaring a Climate Crisis Requiring Urgent and Inclusive Mobilization in Yolo County." This resolution set forth the ambitious goal of achieving a countywide carbon-negative (climate-positive) footprint by 2030 and urged the investment of countywide resources to initiate a just transition to an inclusive, equitable, sustainable, and resilient local economy while also supporting and advocating for regional, national, and international efforts necessary to reverse the climate, social justice, and economic crises. The resolution directed the County to create a working advisory body, the Yolo County Climate Action Commission ("Commission"), to develop and propose a new Climate Action and Adaptation Plan ("CAAP") designed to reduce all greenhouse gas emissions in Yolo County and achieve the County's ambitious climate goals. County staff and the Commission are nearing the end of the CAAP update process, having taken the following steps:
  • November 22, 2022: The Board of Supervisors received an update on CAAP Progress and approved a contract with Dudek for the development of the CAAP.
  • January 2023: County launches CAAP development process. 
  • April 2023: County begins hosting public education and outreach events to solicit input on CAAP strategies and priorities.
  • June 2023: County hosts the first 3 CAAP Community Workshops to solicit input on key climate impacts facing Yolo County community members. 
  • November 2023 - January 2024: County hosts 9 Community Workshops across the County focused on soliciting hyper-local feedback on specific CAAP strategies, measures, and actions. 
  • December 5, 2023: The Board received an update on CAAP Progress and directed staff to include prioritization of programs and projects that support CAAP implementation and the County’s goal of achieving net-negative emissions by 2030 in the 2024-25 Budget Principles.
  • February 26, 2024: Commission approves CAAP Emission Reduction and Adaptation Strategy, Measure, Action List.
  • March 25, 2024: Commission approves Phasing of CAAP Measure, Action List, which identifies top priorities for staff to address in the first three (3) years of CAAP implementation. 
CAAP Engagement to Date
Natural and Working Lands Technical Advisory Committee (NWL TAC)
Given the importance of carbon sequestration and natural climate strategies to meeting the County's net-negative goal, the County established a Natural and Working Lands Technical Advisory Committee, which is facilitated by the Yolo County Resource Conservation District (RCD). The NWL TAC focuses on two primary goals: 1) engaging the agricultural community in the unincorporated area in Yolo County's climate action work related to natural and working lands; 2) providing input into CAAP development related to efforts to both sequester carbon on natural and working lands and reduce greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural operations. The NWL TAC is comprised of RCD staff, the County's Agricultural Commissioner, the Executive Director of the Yolo County Farm Bureau, liaisons from the Climate Action Commission and the Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation, and farmers and ranchers from across the County.

Equity and Engagement Technical Advisory Committee (E&E TAC)
To ensure equity and just transition principles are centered in the CAAP development process, the County established the Equity and Engagement Technical Advisory Committee. The E&E TAC focuses on three primary goals: 1) engaging the community in the unincorporated area of Yolo County in the CAAP development and implementation process; 2) providing input into CAAP development related to Yolo County's goal to establish a just transition; 3) providing input into CAAP development regarding ongoing community engagement during implementation of the plan. The Sustainability Division conducted an extensive public recruitment process to recruit volunteers to join the E&E TAC. The E&E TAC is comprised of community representatives from all 5 County Districts, liaisons from the Yolo Youth Commission and Climate Action Commission, and liaisons from each of the 5 CAAP Community Outreach Partners (described below).

Community Outreach Partners
To ensure that the CAAP development process both builds and maintains relationships with the Yolo County community, the Sustainability Division recruited 5 community-based organizations (CBOs) to serve as paid outreach partners for the CAAP. These partners support CAAP development by engaging the communities they serve in CAAP development and implementation, providing input on outreach activities and communications strategies that will promote and support community engagement, and interacting with the communities they serve to generate input on strategies, policies, and programs that will support a Just Transition to a net negative and sustainable Yolo County. After an extensive recruitment and selection process, the Sustainability Division selected the following five (5) Community Outreach Partners:
  • Center for Land-Based Learning
  • Cool Davis
  • Davis Odd Fellows
  • De Colores Resource Center
  • Yolo County Food Bank
To date, these partnerships have proved invaluable for expanding the reach of County engagement efforts, connecting with historically underrepresented communities, and increasing the number and frequency of local-level engagement events.

Public Engagement Efforts
In line with the Board's direction that the CAAP center equity, the Sustainability Division has worked with the Commission, NWL TAC, E&E TAC, and the Community Outreach Partners to develop a comprehensive public engagement effort that spans the County's five districts. From April 2023 through March 2024, the Sustainability Division has conducted:
  • 30 Community Tabling Events (ie. pop-up events, tabling at festivals, in partnership with County library branches, etc.)
  • 20 Presentations at Community Meetings (ie. school boards, Citizens Advisory Committees, Chambers of Commerce, etc.)
  • 12 Community Workshops across two workshop series, with a third series scheduled for June.
  • 62 Public Engagement Events Total
CAAP Public Input Survey
To collect public input on the community needs, concerns, and priorities for inclusion in the CAAP, staff developed paper and electronic surveys for distribution at in-person meetings and events and through extensive online channels. The County distributed both a general climate survey for use by the general population, and a Working Lands Survey that was distributed specifically to farmers and ranchers both electronically and via a paper mailer in partnership with the Yolo Resource Conservation District and the Yolo County Farm Bureau. In total, the Sustainability Division received more than 1,000 completed surveys reflecting the climate impacts communities are experiencing, priorities for future program development, and self-reported willingness to adopt practices that reduce individual (or in the case of the Working Lands Survey, a farm or ranch's) carbon footprint. 

Farmworker Testimonials
One of the CAAP Community Outreach Partners, the De Colores Resource Center, conducted outreach to farmworkers in Yolo County to gather testimonials capturing their lived experiences resulting from climate change, and identifying resources farmworkers believe would be most helpful to address physical and mental health impacts. Farmworkers were presented with 2 prompts:
1. How have you been affected by climate events (extreme heat, droughts, wildfires, excessive rain etc.) whether that be at home or at work?
2. What types of resources would have been helpful to you during those situations?

Conversations occurred individually, in groups, or during a Farmworker Health Retreat where De Colores facilitated a Climate Stress Workshop. Collectively, De Colores developed a series of narratives representing the voices of 80 farmworkers. 

County Green Team
Yolo County's climate net-negative goal is one of the most ambitious of any jurisdiction in the nation and meeting it will require interdepartmental partnership and collaboration. For this reason, the Sustainability Division, in partnership with the County Administrators Office, launched a CAAP Steering Committee (known as the "Green Team"), an internal review team that will ground truth and provide input on the strategies and actions being considered for inclusion in the CAAP. The Green Team—which includes representatives from the County Administrators Office, Department of Agriculture, Department of Community Services, Department of Financial Services, Department of General Services, the Health and Human Services Agency, and Office of Emergency Services—has been tasked with reviewing and providing input on the strategies, measures, and actions being considered for the CAAP and discussing creative funding strategies to support this interdepartmental effort.

CAAP Strategy, Measure, Action Framework
Framework Overview
Based on input from the Commission, Green Team, and the public, the CAAP outlines 10 key strategies for achieving emissions reduction and climate adaptation goals:
  1. Decarbonize Transportation 
  2. Reduce Vehicle Miles Traveled
  3. Decarbonize Energy and Buildings and Increase Energy Efficiency
  4. Optimize Water Use
  5. Minimize Waste 
  6. Reduce Offroad Equipment Emissions
  7. Support Climate-Smart Agriculture
  8. Sequester and Store Carbon in Natural and Working Lands
  9. Reduce Carbon Footprint of Consumption and Production 
  10. Build Resilient Infrastructure and Healthy Communities 
Measures 
Each of the ten (10) strategies above is further organized by relevant measures to achieve the given strategy objective. In total, there are 39 Measures included in the CAAP (outlined in Att. A). Measures are focused on the sector-, or sub-sector–specific objectives that are achieved through individual implementing actions, described below. For each measure, co-benefits will be noted along with the estimated GHG reduction or sequestration potential for the following milestones: 2027, 2030, and 2045. Various performance objectives and/or tracking metrics will be identified for each measure to assess the success of implementation. Due to the number of individual actions being included in the CAAP, GHG emissions reductions will be measured at the “Measure” level (hence the name).  

Actions  
Below each measure are individual actions, which are specific policies, programs, or tools to be implemented. The actions will include activities that can be documented and used in monitoring progress toward the implementation of the Measures and Strategies. Each action will include a responsible implementer and performance standards that are designed to assist with tracking by the implementing department. In addition, each action will include: partners (noting municipal or community), approximate cost, and if the action is quantitative or qualitative. Funding opportunities will be identified for actions as well. 

Phasing
Implementation of the CAAP will be organized into three main phases as outlined below.  
  • Phase 1: 2024 to 2027 (first three years) 
  • Phase 2: 2027-2030 (next three years) 
  • Phase 3: 2030-2045 (post-2030 future/unknowns)  
Phasing Criteria 
Measures and actions are phased based on a variety of criteria that assess suitability for achieving overall climate action, adaptation, equity, and Just Transition goals. Together with a defined scoring mechanism, the phasing scheme provides an intentional roadmap for CAAP implementation. Below are nine criteria identified as important considerations for phasing. Each action has been scored across the 9 criteria on a scale of 1 to 3 (with higher scores corresponding with earlier phasing). The definition of each category and the relative scoring weight of each category is included below.  

While all 39 measures in the plan are important, it is simply not possible to address all in Phase 1. County staff need temporal direction to focus our efforts and enable us to tackle actions systematically. It is important to note that the weighting is based on the ambitious and accelerated emission reduction and adaptation goals for 2030. For this reason, Criteria 1: Greenhouse Gas Reduction Potential/Adaptation Value and Criteria 2: Foundational/Unlocking actions received the highest relative weighting. 
  1. Greenhouse Gas Reduction Potential/Adaptation Value: The potential GHG emission reductions and/or carbon sequestration potential from each action or the value of the adaptation action. (Weighting: 32%)
  2. Foundational/Unlocking: Actions that are necessary for the implementation of future actions (Weighting: 26%)
  3. Cost-Effectiveness: High-level cost and savings to the County government, residents, and/or businesses with implementation of the action. (Weighting: 10%)
  4. Funding Available: Assesses whether adequate funding exists, and if barriers or challenges will prevent funding. (Weighting: 8%)
  5. Enhance Equity: Considers if the action enhances equity for disadvantaged populations and provides for a fair distribution of benefits/services. (Weighting: 10%
  6. Co-Benefits: Benefits to the community from actions beyond the primary benefits of GHG emission reductions and climate resiliency (e.g., improved air quality, energy independence). (Weighting: 4%)
  7. Community Interest: Reflects if the community expressed interest in this action through outreach and engagement efforts. (Weighting: 3%
    • Note: The relatively lower rating of Community Interest is because, given the nature of the process and the exceedingly high number of actions proposed, the public did not provide extensive feedback on every action. The County's consulting team wanted to avoid having an assumed level of interest impact the phasing. That said, of the top-10 priorities identified by the Community during the most recent round of CAAP workshops (Att. B.), 8 have been identified as Phase 1 priorities, and 2 have been identified as Phase 2 priorities.  
  8. Technologically Feasible: If technology to implement the action is available now, soon, or in the future. (Weighting: 4%
  9. Local Governance & Control: If the County has local control over the action or if it requires state or federal action or funding. (Weighting: 3%)
Staffing Structure Moving Forward
Balancing the demands of CAAP implementation and tracking with the delivery of existing community-facing sustainability programs will require an increase in staffing for the Sustainability Division. The Sustainability Division has requested two (2) additional Associate Administrative Services Analysts (AASA) to support the two top emissions reduction/sequestration priorities of the CAAP:
  • One AASA would oversee implementation of CAAP Strategies Related to Building and Transportation Electrification Programs (Strategies 1, 2, and 3 above - the sectors responsible for the majority of GHG emissions Countywide), as well as the following soon-to-launch programs:
    • Zero Emission Vehicle Action Plan (in partnership with all 4 cities, UC Davis, and the Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation)
    • Inventory and Feasibility Study to Remove Fossil Fuels from County Operations (in partnership with DGS)
    • Electrification Retrofit Rebate Outreach program (in partnership with Valley Clean Energy)
    • Home Energy Score Program (in partnership with Valley Clean Energy and the City of Davis)
    • Home Weatherization Program
  • The other AASA would oversee implementation of CAAP Strategies Related to Natural and Working Lands Programs (Strategies 7 and 8 above - our biggest potential for carbon sequestration/emissions reduction Countywide), as well as the following: 
    • Overseeing the Natural and Working Lands Technical Advisory Committee (in partnership with the Yolo Resource Conservation District). 
    • Overseeing exploration of a Carbon Credit Exchange to fund carbon sequestration processes. 
    • Pursuing funding opportunities to fund carbon sequestration processes. 
    • Developing Technical Assistance offerings for farmers and ranchers to pursue carbon farming practices. 
Both AASA positions would support grant-writing related to their program areas, minimizing the general fund impact of future CAAP implementation, and would supervise CivicSpark Fellow(s) to support with program delivery and continue to build Division capacity. 

Next Steps
  • April 2024:
    • County Staff and the Dudek Consulting Team will finalize the updated GHG Inventory for the County (utilizing 2022 data). 
    • County Staff will complete internal review of Draft Climate Action and Adaptation Plan. 
  • June 2024:
    • Draft CAAP will become available for Public Review (30-day public comment period).
    • County Staff will host Draft CAAP Workshops (tentatively 3 in-person, including one fully in Spanish, and 2 virtual).
  • July 2024: Public Comment Period Ends.
  • August/September 2024: Prepare Final CAAP based on public input received. 
  • October 2024:
    • Staff returns to the Board to recommend the adoption of Final CAAP.  
    • Staff allocates remaining Climate Action ARP funds to critical Phase 1 CAAP Priorities. 
    • Staff launches CAAP Tracking Dashboard to ensure transparency in CAAP implementation progress. 
Collaborations (including Board advisory groups and external partner agencies)
Yolo County Climate Action Commission, Equity & Engagement Technical Advisory Committee, Natural and Working Lands Technical Advisory Committee; Department of General Services; County Administrators Office; Department of Financial Services; Health and Human Services Agency; Office of Emergency Services; Department of Agriculture; Board Subcommittee on Climate; Yolo Resource Conservation District; Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation; UC Davis; Yolo Transportation District. 

Fiscal Impact
No Fiscal Impact
Fiscal Impact (Expenditure)
Total cost of recommended action:    $   0
Amount budgeted for expenditure:    $   0
Additional expenditure authority needed:    $  
On-going commitment (annual cost):    $  
Source of Funds for this Expenditure
$0
Attachments
Att. A. Draft CAAP Strategy Measure Framework
Att. B. Summary of Community Requests from CAAP Workshop Series #2
Att. C. Presentation

Form Review
Inbox Reviewed By Date
Stephanie Cormier Stephanie Cormier 03/28/2024 01:12 PM
Leslie Lindbo Leslie Lindbo 03/28/2024 01:50 PM
Stephanie Cormier Stephanie Cormier 03/28/2024 05:26 PM
Leslie Lindbo Leslie Lindbo 03/29/2024 10:02 AM
Berenice Espitia Berenice Espitia 04/02/2024 10:28 AM
Form Started By: Kristen Wraithwall Started On: 03/18/2024 11:34 AM
Final Approval Date: 04/02/2024

    

Level double AA conformance,
                W3C WAI Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0

AgendaQuick ©2005 - 2024 Destiny Software Inc. All Rights Reserved.